Why a lawsuit was filed one day after deadly New Mexico truck crash

In the late summer of 2018, a terrible collision between a bus and a semi-truck shut down a New Mexico highway. The next day, a truck crash lawsuit was filed in court. Here’s what happened.


A Greyhound bus carrying almost 50 people was headed west along I-40. A semi-truck headed east on I-40 swerved across the median and slammed into the bus.

CBS News_Lawsuit in truck bus crash New Mexico_Coluccio
Video shows incredible destruction at the scene of the fatal semi-truck and bus collision in New Mexico last week


The crash was severe. Many bus passengers were injured, and at least eight have died from their injuries.

In the aftermath of the collision, police said the semi-truck lost the tread on its left front tire, which caused it to swerve into the oncoming lane.

A lawsuit was filed the next day. 

I can’t speak for the attorney representing two of the deceased bus passengers, and I have no affiliation with the case. However, I have more than three decades of experience in truck crash lawsuits.

Here’s why I think they filed a truck crash lawsuit within hours of the deadly Greyhound-semi-truck crash.

CBS news_Lawsuit filed in truck bus crash_Coluccio Law
The day after the crash, a lawsuit was filed against trucking company JAG Transportation Inc. (Click image for video link).

Preservation of Evidence

By filing a lawsuit immediately, the attorneys for the families of the deceased crash victims can get a court order requiring the trucking company to preserve evidence.

While the court can’t force a defendant to preserve evidence from a fatal crash, they can be punished for not doing so. This is important: some companies could act quickly to destroy any evidence that they are liable for the crash, or simply fail to properly preserve evidence.

In this case, it will be crucial for the plaintiffs’ attorneys to be able to inspect the records of service and maintenance on the truck tires, as well as the tires themselves

They will also need to access the Electronic Logging Data (ELD) for the truck driver, and the “black box” for information about what happened before the collision.

Interviewing Witnesses

The truck driver told CBS News that the tire “… just locked up.”

Other witnesses, including another commercial truck driver, told reporters that they saw the front tire blow out.

There were dozens of people on the bus, and many motorists who stopped to help. These folks are all potential witnesses, with a different and important perspective.

Protecting their legal rights 

While the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) is investigating the collision, that can take anywhere from two months to two years.

The NTSB report will be valuable, but it may come too late to be of assistance to the injured.

NTSB_Lawsuit filed in truck bus crash_Trucking Watchdog
NTSB investigator examining the wreckage of the bus hit by the tractor-trailer last week.

And the investigation isn’t meant to protect the rights of the injured. The NTSB will examine details, analyze data, and make safety recommendations.

Unfortunately, the fact is that the motor carrier, trucking company, and/or truck driver are unlikely to have enough insurance. The purpose of insurance is to cover all of the damages, medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, disabilities—and compensate for the families of the deceased.

Because the insurance trucking companies must have has not changed in 30 years.

The minimum amount of insurance for a commercial truck in 1980: $750,000.

The minimum amount of insurance for a commercial truck in 2018: $750,000.

Even with better-than-minimum insurance, odds are good that the trucking company won’t be able to pay for the needs of all the seriously injured people. The attorneys may be able to determine others were at fault.

I have, in the past handled a case involving a blown tire that caused the death of a driver.  We were able to determine that a “retread” was at fault.

While “retreads” are not allowed on the first wheels of school buses, nothing prevents their use on the front wheels of semi-trucks.  Many trucking companies use “retreads” to save money.


As stated above my law firm has no affiliation with the attorneys who filed a lawsuit on behalf of New Mexico bus crash victims. The above opinions are based on available information and are not legal advice. 

– Attorney Kevin Coluccio, Coluccio Law, Seattle.

Keep Reading

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Contact Coluccio Law