In Washington, you can still recover after a car crash you partly caused, but your award drops by your share of the blame. A driver found 20% at fault is awarded 80% of proven losses. That percentage decides more than the size of the check. It also affects whether one defendant can be made to pay the full award, and in one narrow situation involving alcohol or drugs, whether you recover anything for your injuries. A Seattle car crash attorney can test the evidence behind the number before you accept an insurer’s version of it.
How Washington Divides Fault After a Crash
Washington uses pure comparative fault. Under the rule Washington applies to shared blame, fault chargeable to the injured person “diminishes proportionately the amount awarded as compensatory damages” but “does not bar recovery.” The same rule covers the injuries to you and the damage to your vehicle.
When more than one party caused the harm, the judge or jury assigns a percentage of fault to each of them, including you. The percentages must add up to 100. For example, if a jury values your losses at $100,000 and finds you 20% at fault. You would recover $80,000. At 40% fault, you would recover $60,000.
An adjuster who says you share the blame is proposing a percentage. The evidence decides whether that percentage holds up if the claim goes to a jury.
What Counts as Your Share of the Fault
Washington defines fault broadly. It includes any act or omission that is “in any measure negligent or reckless toward the person or property of the actor or others.” Careless conduct toward yourself counts as well as conduct that endangers someone else. The definition also includes an “unreasonable failure to avoid an injury or to mitigate damages,” and mitigating damages means limiting the harm once it has happened.
The law weighs two things when it compares fault: “the nature of the conduct” of each person and “the extent of the causal relation between such conduct and the damages.” Put plainly, a judge or jury asks how careless each driver was and how much that carelessness caused the harm.
The mitigation language reaches decisions made after the crash, such as whether to follow recommended treatment. Washington courts give injured people wide latitude here. To use a treatment choice against you, the insurer has to show that a reasonable treatment option was available, that passing it up was unreasonable, and that the choice made your harm worse. Even then, it cuts only the part of your loss that the choice caused. Following your doctor’s instructions and keeping records of your treatment give the insurer less to argue about.
Washington treats the seat belt differently. State law requires drivers and passengers 16 and older to wear one, with limited exceptions. The seat belt statute also provides that failing to comply “does not constitute negligence” and that not wearing a belt is not admissible “as evidence of negligence in any civil action.”
Washington’s Court of Appeals has held that the same rule also blocks using an unbuckled belt to argue that you failed to avoid your injuries or to limit your damages. An adjuster who cites an unbuckled belt as evidence that you were negligent is making an argument Washington law keeps out of a civil lawsuit.
Why Any Share of Fault Changes Who Pays
Shared fault has a second consequence, and it matters in crashes with more than one at-fault driver or company. Under the statute that divides payment among defendants, each defendant’s liability is “several only,” which means each one owes only its percentage of your total damages.
The main exception for a fault-free injured person applies when the judge or jury finds that the injured person was not at fault. In that case, the defendants against whom judgment is entered are jointly and severally liable for the combined amount of their shares. You may recover that combined amount from any one of those defendants. This exception does not include the share of anyone who settled before judgment, was released, was never sued, or is immune from liability. Separate rules can make a party responsible for someone acting as its employee or agent, or make parties acting in concert responsible for one another’s fault.
A three-vehicle crash with $300,000 in proven losses shows the difference:
You Are Found Fault-Free
Driver A is 60% at fault, and Driver B is 40% at fault. Your total damages are $300,000. If judgment is entered against both drivers, they are jointly and severally liable for the full $300,000. Even if Driver B has no insurance or assets, you may recover the full amount from Driver A. If you settle with Driver B before judgment, however, this exception does not make Driver A responsible for B’s 40% share.
You Are Found 10% At Fault
Driver A is 55% at fault, and Driver B is 35% at fault. Your recovery is $270,000, but Driver A owes only $165,000 and Driver B owes $105,000. If Driver B cannot pay, Driver A cannot be made to cover that $105,000. If you have uninsured/underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage, it may help pay Driver B’s unpaid share if B has no liability insurance or insufficient coverage, subject to your policy’s limits and terms. Washington auto policies generally include UIM bodily-injury coverage unless a named insured or spouse rejects all or part of it in writing.
In the second scenario, a 10% finding against you cost $30,000 on paper and put another $105,000 at risk. Even a small percentage deserves a challenge when more than one driver is involved.
The One Situation Where Fault Can End the Claim
Washington has a separate statute that turns a fault finding into a complete defense to an injury claim. Three conditions must all be true:
- The injured person was under the influence of alcohol or any drug when the crash happened
- That condition was a proximate cause of the injury, meaning a legal cause that helped bring it about
- The judge or jury finds the injured person more than 50% at fault
The statute also limits that defense. It does not protect an impaired driver whose impairment helped cause the injury, even when the injured person was also under the influence, as long as the injured person’s condition did not help cause the crash. Outside that situation, the statutes discussed here may reduce a partly at-fault driver’s recovery instead of ending it.
Protecting Your Percentage in the Weeks After the Crash
The fault percentage is built from evidence, and some of that evidence does not last. We move to secure these items first:
- Video from nearby businesses and dashcams
- Names and phone numbers for witnesses
- Photographs of the vehicles, the road surface, and anything that blocked a driver’s view
- Electronic data stored in the vehicles, when it is available
- Your medical records from the first visit forward
We prepare every case as though it may go to trial, and that preparation starts with preserving this material before it is gone.
Speak with a lawyer before you give a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurance company. An apology or a guess about your speed during an interviewl can be quoted back to you when your percentage is argued.
Ask for security footage right away, long before deadlines arrive. Washington sets a three-year deadline to file a lawsuit for an injury to the person, and the same period covers damage to your vehicle. If a government vehicle, employee, or road was involved, Washington also requires you to file a claim with that government on its required claim form before you sue. The claim must be filed within the three-year period, and you must then wait 60 days before filing the lawsuit. The deadline is paused during that 60-day wait.
Always consult with an attorney regarding statute of limitations and any required claims filings. The failure to follow the required statute of limitations and claims filing process would result it a loss of your rights forever.
Talk to Coluccio Law About a Shared-Fault Crash
If an insurance company has told you the crash was partly your fault, that percentage is still open to challenge. Kevin Coluccio has more than 40 years of personal injury litigation experience and has recovered more than $500 million for injured clients and their families. He limits the number of cases he takes, so you work with him directly. Contact Coluccio Law for a free consultation. You pay no attorney fee unless we recover compensation for you.