Blog
A delivery driver hit you, and each company says someone else should pay. DoorDash’s general U.S. terms, which apply in Washington, say its insurance covers injuries a driver causes only while the driver is on an accepted order, so get the app’s record of that moment first.

You were stopped at a light, or crossing in a crosswalk, when a car came through with a Grubhub order on the seat. Now the driver’s insurer says the policy excludes delivery work, and the app company says the driver was never its employee. A lawyer can test both answers. Washington holds employers responsible for employees doing their jobs, and what an app contract calls the driver is only one factor in deciding who counts as an employee. A Seattle delivery driver accident attorney can request the company’s records of what the driver’s app showed at the moment of the crash.

What Makes the Driver Personally Responsible?

The person behind the wheel is responsible for a crash that person caused. A claim against a delivery driver works like any other Seattle car crash claim: the evidence has to show what the driver did wrong. A driver who speeds to meet a delivery window, reads the next order on a phone, or rolls through a stop sign while looking for an address is driving carelessly, and careless driving is what the claim has to prove.

If you are found partly at fault, Washington law usually reduces your compensation by your share of the fault. A narrow exception can bar the claim entirely if the injured person was under the influence of alcohol or drugs, that condition helped cause the injury, and the person is found more than 50 percent at fault.

Your harder problem is finding an insurer that will pay. The driver’s personal auto policy can refuse the claim. The state insurance commissioner warns that most personal auto policies sold in Washington don’t cover gig work, and many policies say so in writing. So you need to know whether the company behind the app shares responsibility.

When Does the App Company Share Responsibility?

Washington law generally holds an employer responsible for injuries caused by an employee’s negligent driving within the scope of employment. Lawyers call this vicarious liability. Breaking a workplace rule does not, by itself, put an employee outside the scope of employment. An employee who also serves a personal purpose during a trip may still be acting within the scope of employment when the employer’s work created the need for the trip.

Washington’s fault statute points the same way. Under RCW 4.22.070, a party is responsible for the fault of a person acting as its servant (the older legal term for an employee) or its agent.

In a crash case, both rules usually depend on whether the driver counts as the company’s employee. DoorDash, for example, signs its drivers to what it calls an Independent Contractor Agreement and requires them to carry auto insurance. An independent contractor is someone hired to do a job without the hiring company controlling how the work gets done.

Why the Contractor Label Is Only the Starting Point

Washington courts decide employee status by asking whether the company controls, or has the right to control, how the worker does the job. In a 1966 decision, the Washington Supreme Court listed the factors that bear on that question, including:

  • How much control the company has over the details of the work
  • Whether the worker runs a distinct business
  • Who supplies the vehicle, tools, and place of work
  • Whether the worker is paid by the hour or by the job
  • Whether the work is part of the company’s regular business

What the parties believe they created is one more factor on the court’s list. The court called control the crucial factor, and when the facts are disputed, a judge or jury decides. The company’s rules, pay records, and app data answer those questions, so a lawyer should start gathering them right away.

Washington’s Rideshare Insurance Law Is Written for Passenger-Ride Companies

Washington requires special rideshare auto coverage on every rideshare vehicle while the driver is logged in to the app, with a $1 million limit during a prearranged ride. The law defines a covered company as one whose app is used to connect passengers to drivers for prearranged rides.

A food or grocery order has no passenger. By its terms, the law covers companies whose apps match drivers with passengers. DoorDash, Grubhub, and Instacart match drivers with food and grocery orders, so a delivery falls outside that definition. If the driver was also logged in to a passenger app such as Uber or Lyft, the law requires rideshare coverage for the whole time the driver was logged in. Until the driver accepts a ride, the required limits are lower: $50,000 per person and $100,000 per crash for injuries, and $30,000 for property damage. Ask which apps the driver had open.

For a delivery, each company’s contracts with its insurers set the coverage. The main rideshare insurance statute, RCW 46.72B.180, also states that nothing in it limits personal-policy exclusions for vehicles used to carry persons or property for a charge, language insurers can point to when denying a delivery claim.

Which Insurance Policy Pays for a Delivery Crash?

For DoorDash, the answer depends on the app’s status at the moment of the crash. The company’s help center says its liability insurance applies from the time a driver accepts a delivery request until the order is marked delivered, unassigned, or canceled. A driver who is online but has not accepted an order relies on a personal auto policy as the primary coverage. 

DoorDash’s terms for the states it does not list separately, which include Washington, also require that the driver be liable for the injury. Those terms state no dollar limit, but DoorDash’s driver insurance page says its coverage may pay up to $1 million for injuries and property damage to others in most states, subject to its policy terms. That page also says that if the driver has a policy that covers delivery work, DoorDash’s coverage may apply only after the driver’s own policy pays.

For a Grubhub or Instacart driver, the same two questions apply. Was the driver on an active order, and what coverage did that company carry at that moment? The company’s records answer both.

Your own auto policy may also help. Washington auto policies include underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage, and insurers must offer personal injury protection (PIP), unless the policyholder turned that coverage down in writing. Washington treats a vehicle as underinsured when no liability insurance applies to the crash or when the driver’s coverage is too low to pay your losses, so UIM coverage may apply if every other insurer says no. PIP can pay medical bills and part of your lost income.

What Evidence Shows the Driver Was on a Delivery?

Collect what you can at the scene, or ask someone to collect it for you:

  • The app the driver was using, and anything that ties the car to it, such as an insulated bag, an order on the phone screen, or a sticker
  • Photos of the vehicle, the license plate, and the scene
  • Names and phone numbers of witnesses
  • The police report number, if officers responded
  • The exact time of the crash

A lawyer can then request the company’s records showing when the driver accepted and completed the order and compare them with the time of the crash. Until you have spoken with a lawyer, hold off on giving a recorded statement to the driver’s insurer or the app company’s insurer.

How Long Do You Have to File in Washington?

Washington gives you three years to file a lawsuit for most personal injury claims, under RCW 4.16.080. Start early. A lawyer needs time to get the app records, sort out which insurer pays, and file before that deadline.

Talk With Kevin Coluccio About Your Delivery Crash

Kevin Coluccio has more than 40 years of personal injury experience and limits the cases he takes so each client works with him directly. We prepare every case as though it may go to trial. Contact Coluccio Law for a free consultation. You pay no attorney fee unless we recover for you.

Injured by a DoorDash, Grubhub, or Instacart Driver? Who’s Liable in Washington
A delivery driver hit you, and each company says someone else should pay. DoorDash’s general U.S. terms, which apply in Washington, say its insurance covers injuries a driver causes only while the driver is on an accepted order, so get the app’s record of that moment first.

You were stopped at a light, or crossing in a crosswalk, when a car came through with a Grubhub order on the seat. Now the driver’s insurer says the policy excludes delivery work, and the app company says the driver was never its employee. A lawyer can test both answers. Washington holds employers responsible for employees doing their jobs, and what an app contract calls the driver is only one factor in deciding who counts as an employee. A Seattle delivery driver accident attorney can request the company’s records of what the driver’s app showed at the moment of the crash.

What Makes the Driver Personally Responsible?

The person behind the wheel is responsible for a crash that person caused. A claim against a delivery driver works like any other Seattle car crash claim: the evidence has to show what the driver did wrong. A driver who speeds to meet a delivery window, reads the next order on a phone, or rolls through a stop sign while looking for an address is driving carelessly, and careless driving is what the claim has to prove.

If you are found partly at fault, Washington law usually reduces your compensation by your share of the fault. A narrow exception can bar the claim entirely if the injured person was under the influence of alcohol or drugs, that condition helped cause the injury, and the person is found more than 50 percent at fault.

Your harder problem is finding an insurer that will pay. The driver’s personal auto policy can refuse the claim. The state insurance commissioner warns that most personal auto policies sold in Washington don’t cover gig work, and many policies say so in writing. So you need to know whether the company behind the app shares responsibility.

When Does the App Company Share Responsibility?

Washington law generally holds an employer responsible for injuries caused by an employee’s negligent driving within the scope of employment. Lawyers call this vicarious liability. Breaking a workplace rule does not, by itself, put an employee outside the scope of employment. An employee who also serves a personal purpose during a trip may still be acting within the scope of employment when the employer’s work created the need for the trip.

Washington’s fault statute points the same way. Under RCW 4.22.070, a party is responsible for the fault of a person acting as its servant (the older legal term for an employee) or its agent.

In a crash case, both rules usually depend on whether the driver counts as the company’s employee. DoorDash, for example, signs its drivers to what it calls an Independent Contractor Agreement and requires them to carry auto insurance. An independent contractor is someone hired to do a job without the hiring company controlling how the work gets done.

Why the Contractor Label Is Only the Starting Point

Washington courts decide employee status by asking whether the company controls, or has the right to control, how the worker does the job. In a 1966 decision, the Washington Supreme Court listed the factors that bear on that question, including:

  • How much control the company has over the details of the work
  • Whether the worker runs a distinct business
  • Who supplies the vehicle, tools, and place of work
  • Whether the worker is paid by the hour or by the job
  • Whether the work is part of the company’s regular business

What the parties believe they created is one more factor on the court’s list. The court called control the crucial factor, and when the facts are disputed, a judge or jury decides. The company’s rules, pay records, and app data answer those questions, so a lawyer should start gathering them right away.

Washington’s Rideshare Insurance Law Is Written for Passenger-Ride Companies

Washington requires special rideshare auto coverage on every rideshare vehicle while the driver is logged in to the app, with a $1 million limit during a prearranged ride. The law defines a covered company as one whose app is used to connect passengers to drivers for prearranged rides.

A food or grocery order has no passenger. By its terms, the law covers companies whose apps match drivers with passengers. DoorDash, Grubhub, and Instacart match drivers with food and grocery orders, so a delivery falls outside that definition. If the driver was also logged in to a passenger app such as Uber or Lyft, the law requires rideshare coverage for the whole time the driver was logged in. Until the driver accepts a ride, the required limits are lower: $50,000 per person and $100,000 per crash for injuries, and $30,000 for property damage. Ask which apps the driver had open.

For a delivery, each company’s contracts with its insurers set the coverage. The main rideshare insurance statute, RCW 46.72B.180, also states that nothing in it limits personal-policy exclusions for vehicles used to carry persons or property for a charge, language insurers can point to when denying a delivery claim.

Which Insurance Policy Pays for a Delivery Crash?

For DoorDash, the answer depends on the app’s status at the moment of the crash. The company’s help center says its liability insurance applies from the time a driver accepts a delivery request until the order is marked delivered, unassigned, or canceled. A driver who is online but has not accepted an order relies on a personal auto policy as the primary coverage. 

DoorDash’s terms for the states it does not list separately, which include Washington, also require that the driver be liable for the injury. Those terms state no dollar limit, but DoorDash’s driver insurance page says its coverage may pay up to $1 million for injuries and property damage to others in most states, subject to its policy terms. That page also says that if the driver has a policy that covers delivery work, DoorDash’s coverage may apply only after the driver’s own policy pays.

For a Grubhub or Instacart driver, the same two questions apply. Was the driver on an active order, and what coverage did that company carry at that moment? The company’s records answer both.

Your own auto policy may also help. Washington auto policies include underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage, and insurers must offer personal injury protection (PIP), unless the policyholder turned that coverage down in writing. Washington treats a vehicle as underinsured when no liability insurance applies to the crash or when the driver’s coverage is too low to pay your losses, so UIM coverage may apply if every other insurer says no. PIP can pay medical bills and part of your lost income.

What Evidence Shows the Driver Was on a Delivery?

Collect what you can at the scene, or ask someone to collect it for you:

  • The app the driver was using, and anything that ties the car to it, such as an insulated bag, an order on the phone screen, or a sticker
  • Photos of the vehicle, the license plate, and the scene
  • Names and phone numbers of witnesses
  • The police report number, if officers responded
  • The exact time of the crash

A lawyer can then request the company’s records showing when the driver accepted and completed the order and compare them with the time of the crash. Until you have spoken with a lawyer, hold off on giving a recorded statement to the driver’s insurer or the app company’s insurer.

How Long Do You Have to File in Washington?

Washington gives you three years to file a lawsuit for most personal injury claims, under RCW 4.16.080. Start early. A lawyer needs time to get the app records, sort out which insurer pays, and file before that deadline.

Talk With Kevin Coluccio About Your Delivery Crash

Kevin Coluccio has more than 40 years of personal injury experience and limits the cases he takes so each client works with him directly. We prepare every case as though it may go to trial. Contact Coluccio Law for a free consultation. You pay no attorney fee unless we recover for you.

Website developed in accordance with Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.2.
If you encounter any issues while using this site, please contact us: 206.826.8201